Low cost seperation help

Status
Not open for further replies.
D

dsrtrat

New member
I am new to the forum and soon to be newly seperated.

We both (soon to be ex and myself) agree that making the lawyers rich is not our goal. I think we are both sensible enough to settle things at the kitchen table.

My question is, what is the cheapest way to do this without making mistakes that will bite us down the road? We have a good idea of who is getting what but need some legal advice on where to start. We will need new mortgages, a seperation agreement that includes division of assets, childcare and support, spousal support and yadda yadda yadda.

Where do you start?
 
Both of you read Surviving your Divorce.

Then read it again, make notes along the way for each chapter. If something doesn't apply to you, note why. If it does apply to you, note what you think.

Sit down and discuss each other's notes.

Look at this, Equalization Spreadsheet.

I was going to send you to "My support calculator" but the website is down. Maybe it will work tomorrow. My Support Calculator.

Support Calculator is now working again.
 
You should start here - so good job!

You should understand the basic concepts. Ultimately you can decide to any agreement you want (though aspects of it may be overturned if one of you changes their mind later - such as non standard child support).

So my view of 'by the book' for married couples with children (and assuming you had nothing when you met).

1. Equalization - you both walk away with the same net worth - does not matter who keeps what, as long as you have the same net worth - this means including everything (RRSP, pension, debts, credit cards, cash, assets, houses, everything).
2. Child access - you both live with the kids equally and neither parent is designated 'primary'. A good way to do it is '2/2/3' schedule (Mon/Tues - mom, Wed/Thurs - dad, alternate weekends).
3. Child Support - Use current income to lookup amount in CS tables. Subtract difference and greater income earner pays the other the difference (the 'offset method'). This is updated yearly according to income July 1 based on previous year tax return. Work together to share expenses not associated specifically with one home such as sports, medical, clothing, post secondary.
4. Spousal Support - What ever makes sense and whatever you agree to. You can use the SSAG as a guideline. See MySupportCalculator.ca
5. You don't move out until you have a signed separation agreement that states this.
6. You both get your own lawyer to give you ILA Independent Legal Advice. You DO NOT let the lawyers take over - they work for you! You adjust the separation agreement according to their advice.
7. You sign it with witnesses etc.
8. You live happily ever after.

Simple.
 
Last edited:
Keep friends, family members and girlfriends/boyfriends out of everything. If you need someone else's opinion make sure the people you turn to have nothing to gain/lose by your decisions. Get professional counselling or borrow a dog to walk. DO NOT get other people involved.

Good luck and hope you have happy trails ahead of you.
 
Keep the TRUST between yourselves. That makes everything possible.

Aside from equalization, which is one once, then enables you to live financially separate, realize that all decisions on shared parenting can be changed down the road as needed.

Acknowledge the possibility of future partners, and that they will take on a parenting role. Sometimes it all goes off the rails when someone new enters the picture: **it's a STRANGER!!!** <--- Trust in your partner's judgment.

Acknowledge that each of you will be parenting INDEPENDENTLY i.e. there will be many details not shared with the other. This can be a BIG mental adjustment. <--- Trust in your partner's judgment.

With shared custody, you both will be sharing in the expenses. ... discuss how this will work i.e. who buys the clothes, major sporting gear, electronics, and school supplies? What level of 'accounting' do you need to check that you are both contributing your proper share?

Are there any areas where you have fundamental differences in parenting approach? Acknowledge these up front, and as much as possible, agree that you will each do your own thing in your own household.

The following is a guide for developing a very detailed sample parenting plan - these would be good discussion points:
http://www.albertacourts.ab.ca/cs/familyjustice/CTS0907.pdf
 
Thanks fo rthe info folks.

We are looking at the assets right now. I have agreed to move out of the house once we are seperated for the kids sake. We have two girls that will want to spend more time with their mom than me. She will be primary but were not set on the ratio yet. I know it has to 60/40 minimum for the CS to be looked at in a shared custody.

I will read those links and go from there. KNowing that I am going to need a house in the near future, we will have to agree on an amount for our current home's value and get to work setting up new mortgages so I can get shopping.

Feeling a little overwhelemd right now. Luckily, we know this is for the best and have no illusion's that it will be easy but we are both against filling the pockets of two lawyers at the expense of our own and kid's financial future.

I have a question about gifts. For the last 10 years, her parents, my parents and even my wife have always given me cash. I know it sounds cold but I was always looking for specialty tools that they could not buy. Any money she received she used for stuff like braces on her teeth. The end result is I have a bunch of used tools that were purchased with gift money and she has a straight smile. Are my items considered gifts that I received and not part of the the equalization process?


cheers.
 
dsrtrat said:
I have agreed to move out of the house once we are seperated for the kids sake. We have two girls that will want to spend more time with their mom than me.
Click to expand...

Please re-examine what you believe in your value as a dad.

This is the ONE thing that will be difficult to change down the road, or even tomorrow, now you have discussed and verbally agreed.

Have a look at the CS guidelines, and see how the numbers work out for you and her if you are fully involved with say 35% time, are active with the kids, maintain a home for them, taking them on vacations ... and are paying the table amounts. Really, the costs in your 2 households are going to be similar (except maybe she does all the clothes buying - which will be maybe 10-15% of your CS payment?)

Re the tools/dentistry - it is unlikely that the 'kijiji' value (that's what you should use for comparing $'s) of these is more than a few thousand ... and she has a smile that lasts a lifetime. If this becomes an argument, you are likely in for more trouble with other stuff. But, the general rule is that gifts *from 3rd parties* are excluded from the assets to be divided.

I'm assuming that you meant 'the giving of cash as presents' was cold? Not your approach to splitting them?
 
Last edited:
arabian said:
Keep friends, family members and girlfriends/boyfriends out of everything. If you need someone else's opinion make sure the people you turn to have nothing to gain/lose by your decisions. Get professional counselling or borrow a dog to walk. DO NOT get other people involved.

Good luck and hope you have happy trails ahead of you.
Click to expand...

Standard advice from arabian - she has issues with other people influencing her ex - take with a (large) grain of salt.
 
dsrtrat said:
...
I have a question about gifts. For the last 10 years, her parents, my parents and even my wife have always given me cash. I know it sounds cold but I was always looking for specialty tools that they could not buy. Any money she received she used for stuff like braces on her teeth. The end result is I have a bunch of used tools that were purchased with gift money and she has a straight smile. Are my items considered gifts that I received and not part of the the equalization process?


cheers.
Click to expand...

They are part of equalization - you are correct, it does sound cold and is not reasonable - marriage is an emotional AND financial agreement - split all things 50/50
 
would they be considering the money was a gift to one person and not to them as a couple?? If he bought something with the money that was for his use alone would that not be cosidered excluded as compared to a new dining room set that they both used??
 
But Arabian is correct about this.Often when marriages hit the rocks and people outside become involved ,they try to push their agendas onto your divorce.If they had a bad divorce they will convince you to destroy your ex(not that it helps them but because they are indenial over their portion of blame in their own marriage).Then some will say "i never liked her etc,why are you giving her anything"...this may even include stuff that wasn't your to begin with.

BUT remember this-if you start taking bad advice and dragging others into it ,your ex will be threatened and will look to people to back her too.Soon you will have a full out war with your kids in the middle of it,costing both of you a fortune and the only benefit being is that the assholes who pushed you down the wrong track ,have suffered nothing whatsoever.Opinions are like assholes ,everyone has one. Be very careful whose advice you take.
On a lighter note it is refreshing to hear someone with a logical thought out game plan and a genuine concern for their family.I really do hope this goes well for you.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I would tend to disagree. I find Bill's posts quite balanced and unbiased. He'll call you on your shit whether you're a guy or a gal.
 
Just curious as to where to start? I will get the surviving divorce book but it is not in my hands right now. Assuming we can get a deal done at the kitchen table, we still have questions and will need guidance. Is there someone who can help without being a typical manipulative asshole lawyer that will attempt to draw us into a costly war? What do people do when they want to settle without a war and a huge lawyer bill but have many questions?
 
If you're looking at hammering out a seperation agreement between the two of you, each of you should sit down and outline what you want to see happen and your expectations, then see how far apart you are on your issues and how much you can move towards agreeing on things on your own before paying someone to help you get there. There are some really great sample seperation agreements out there that can help you get started and identify what areas need to be looked at:

Checklist for separation agreements in Canada

Ontario Divorce and Family Law

Ontario property divorce laws

Child support Canada

Ontario Spousal Support (Alimony) Menu

Those links should help you get started.
 
Talk to a mediator who is a family law lawyer. They will help you enter an agreement that respects the law and reflects both people.

It's much cheaper than retaining lawyers to negotiate/escalate but it will still cost a bit. A typical separation agreement costs around $1500-2000 to be drafted. You sit down with the mediator to help work out the details you want and they will draft the resulting agreement for you.
 
blinkandimgone said:
I would tend to disagree. I find Bill's posts quite balanced and unbiased. He'll call you on your shit whether you're a guy or a gal.
Click to expand...

Ok I was a bit harsh ,I usually like Bills posts myself but I stand by the theory.We DO need our family and friends for support and comfort in this hard time but they should not be our first port of call when seeking legal advice.Unless your buddy is a lawyer.Generally our friends and family are so biased about how awesome we are that they cant give unbiased opinions and advice.

I apologise Billm..It was a pre coffee bit of stupid before my brain started functioning.:o
 
Mess said:
Both of you read Surviving your Divorce.

Then read it again, make notes along the way for each chapter. If something doesn't apply to you, note why. If it does apply to you, note what you think.

Sit down and discuss each other's notes.

Look at this, Equalization Spreadsheet.

I was going to send you to "My support calculator" but the website is down. Maybe it will work tomorrow. My Support Calculator.

Support Calculator is now working again.
Click to expand...

I nominate this to be a permanent sticky on the board. In fact, it should be re-written as a standard "welcome to the board" message probably. In fact, I would be all for an update to the CLRA to require upon application that both parties demonstrate they have completed the steps highlighted in bold (in the quote) prior to filing an Application before the court.

Yes, radical but, would save a lot of pain and agony for many if litigants can demonstrate to the court that they are aware of what they are getting into. The current information (mandatory) requirements is not enough in my honest opinion.

Also, having to hear judges tell litigants that what they fought about could be found in any book at the library or chapters on several occasions now... Tends to suggest that litigants are not investing time in understanding the change in the family situation, their children's "best interests" and seeking good advice.

Good Luck!
Tayken
 
BTW book available in google play store for 19.99
Surviving Your Divorce: A Guide To Canadian Family Law

amazon link provided shows...
4 new from CDN$ 37.28 7 used from CDN$ 0.46

The same author also has

Do We Need a Cohabitation Agreement: Understanding How a Legal Contract Can Strengthen Your Life Together

Description
You're committed, you're moving in together and you're blending your households. But are you forgetting something?
Many Canadians find themselves in common-law relationships and think that they aren't any different from a legal marriage. It can be a shock to find out that, when the going gets tough, certain rights under the law-not to mention financial obligations-do or do not apply. For instance, if one common-law partner becomes seriously ill or passes away, will the other be able to access joint bank accounts? Their shared home? What happens if there is no will? And what about the kids?
These are some of the many serious questions that couples need to consider before sharing their lives, all of which can be addressed in a cohabitation agreement. A cohabitation agreement allows a couple to make sure their partner and any children are taken care of in times of need or crisis; that ownership in properties or financial resources are clear, combined, separated or protected. Most of all, these contracts allow for the peace of mind that comes with having a game plan in place should the relationship end due to death or separation.
Take the advice of Michael Cochrane, a lawyer with more than 30 years of experience, and consider the numerous issues that can affect a common-law relationship. Do We Need a Cohabitation Agreement? is written in clear, nontechnical language and includes real-life examples based on Canadian cases. Cochrane addresses critical issues such as wills and estates, powers of attorney, the special concerns of step-families and same-sex couples, and how to have this discussion with your partner. It will also help you work in a cost-effective way with a lawyer should you decide that an agreement will benefit your relationship.
This is your future together. Get it right from the very beginning.
Click to expand...

which may be interesting as issue come up often. And

Do We Need a Marriage Contract: Understanding How a Legal Agreement Can Strengthen Your Life Together

Description
Congratulations! You've decided to get married. It's a wonderful time, but there's more to think about than just the perfect wedding and honeymoon.
Marriage is more complicated than it used to be. People are marrying later in life and perhaps for the second or third time. Often they are bringing more assets and more liabilities into the relationship, blending children from previous relationships, and generally facing all kinds of new challenges. Marriage contracts, wills and Powers of Attorney are all valuable ways to set your expectations in advance.
Do We Need a Marriage Contract? is written in clear, nontechnical language and includes real-life examples based on Canadian cases. Cochrane includes a sample marriage contract to address the critical issues you need to be aware of, including:
Protection of assets brought into the marriage
The special practical and financial concerns of blending children into new families
Family pressure to have a marriage contract
Business pressure to have a marriage contract
How to have a discussion with your partner and not spoil the romance
How marriage contracts work with your wills and Powers of Attorney
How to work in a cost-effective way with a lawyer
How to avoid the relationship mistakes that lead to divorce
This is your future together. Get it right from the very beginning. Take the advice of Michael Cochrane, a lawyer with more than 30 years of experience in family law, and carefully consider the numerous issues that can affect your relationship.
Click to expand...
 
Murphy's law - no need to defend me. BillM and Blink always try to take a cheap shot at me when the opportunity arises.

Yes indeed I do have an issue with new g/f's/b/f's getting involved with divorce process. It simply is not their business. When a new g/f hides assets and aids in fraudulent acts against you, you will understand.

Remarks from BillM et al are totally uncalled for and simply pathetic.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top