Can I Deny Access?

One of the most common questions I get asked is “Can I deny access of the children to the other parent?”

The short answer is a resounding NO! There is really only one reason you can deny access and that is if there is good reason to believe that the children will be harmed by the other parent. It can’t just be a suspicion or hunch that harm will occur. For instance, even if the other parent is alcoholic, as long as they do not abuse alcohol when the children are around, the alcoholism itself isn’t reason enough to deny access. It is a basic principle of family law that normally children are better off if both parents are involved in their lives and have a relationship with them. A simple fear for your children’s safety is not enough reason to deny access – you must be able to point to something concrete.

If you do have a concern about the other parent, instead of denying access, you should either be discussing your concern with your lawyer or with the Children’s Aid Society.

Of course, no one simply asks whether they can deny access. There is always a good reason. However, what you may believe to be a good reason is not necessarily what the law believes is a good reason.

Example #1. You don’t like your ex’s new partner. From a legal point of view, it doesn’t matter what you think of the parenting abilities of your ex’s new partner. You ex is trusted to make decisions that are in the children’s best interests while the children are with them. These decisions include with which people the children can interact.

Example #2. The children are ill. Unless the children are sick enough to be in the hospital, they normally can be transported to the other parent’s house for care.

Example #3. When you are not being paid support. The issues of access and child support are considered independent issues by the law. You have legal remedies to collect support you are entitled to – don’t make your children pawns in the dispute with your ex.

Other reasons I’ve seen why a parent will want to deny access:
* doesn’t agree on holiday plans or want the children to leave the country
* the other parent picks up the child late
* you are not happy with the other parent’s living accommodations – e.g. children don’t have their own rooms, only a shower and not a bath, etc.
* you have relatives in town visiting you with whom the children want to spend time

If the children say they don’t want to see the other parent, you need to investigate this more deeply. They could feel this way for any number of reasons, some benign, and some serious. If it just because it makes them feel disloyal to you, then that is not sufficient to deny access.

If you have been denied access, you should check out our suggestions as to what to do. Unfortunately, if denial of access happens regularly, it is in your (and your child’s best interests) to proceed to court quickly.

The End of No-Fault Divorce? The Leskun Case

No Fault Divorce

The Supreme Court of Canada released the Leskun decision today: http://scc.lexum.org/decisia-scc-csc/scc-csc/scc-csc/en/item/2298/index.do In this case, the husband had an affair that led to the end of the marriage. Ms Leskun claimed that 8 years … [Continue reading]

Unwed Fathers’ Rights and Responsibilities

Unwed Father holding baby.

In her comments on my post about the so-called Roe v. Wade case for men, Jenny raises a number of interesting questions about what rights and responsibilities an unwed father in Canada has in regards to his unborn children when he is no longer in a … [Continue reading]

Support & RRSPs, Stock Options, Severance, Retirement Allowances, Capital Gains

nonrecurring income

Most people involved in a family law case in Canada know that the amount of spousal support or child support that must be paid is based on income. However, often people receive one-off payments during a year that they don't normally receive - this is … [Continue reading]

Roe v. Wade for Men

When a women gets pregnant, there is a defined period during which she can make a choice about what to do with the baby - raise the child, put the child up for adoption, or have an abortion. However, as the law stands right now, men don't have any … [Continue reading]

Overcoming the 8 Roadblocks to Settling Your Divorce

In my last post, I discussed 8 roadblocks to settling your divorce. They are not easy to overcome, yet they are the reason that many divorce cases become so difficult to resolve. My preferred method for dealing with a lot of these roadblocks is … [Continue reading]

8 Roadblocks to Settling Your Divorce

Many times in my practice, once I am familiar with all the facts of a case (including both my client's version and the version of my client's spouse) I can predict a range of outcomes that's normally very accurate. Despite this, it can be difficult … [Continue reading]

How To Succed At Your Questioning (Examination for Discovery)

In Ontario, what was previously known as an examination for discovery is now called questioning. I've previously discussed what questioning is. There was an extensive discussion in our forum about how stressful questioning is. Here are 8 … [Continue reading]

8 Tips for Dealing with Denial of Access

access denial

One of the most difficult things to deal with in family law is when one parent denies access to the other. This normally occurs in one of two ways: (1) simply not dropping off the children for access or not being around when the other parent arrives … [Continue reading]

OttawaDivorce.com Encourages Fraud?

So, somebody's made a complaint to the Law Society about my web site and, in particular, about this page that deals with child support. While I haven't yet received a copy of the complaint, apparently the essence of the complaint is that this page … [Continue reading]

Family Law Alert Newsletter

You can now subscribe to my blog via email. Simply fill your email address in to the little box under my photo, and click the "subscribe me!" button. It's kind of a neat technology that every night takes my postings, converts them to email, and … [Continue reading]

National Organization of Women Contradicts Itself

No fault divorce means that you can obtain a divorce without proving that either spouse has done something wrong. In Canada, the divorce laws were overhauled in 1968, and since then it has been possible to obtain a divorce without proving … [Continue reading]

Unjust Enrichment

When an unmarried couple separates, there is no automatic division of property. Each party keeps what is in his or her own name. If this result is not satisfactory, it may be possible to make a claim for unjust enrichment. I discuss this in … [Continue reading]

Retroactive Child Support

On February 13, 2006, the Supreme Court of Canada heard arguments about whether child support should be varied retroactively when the support recipient has delayed requesting an increase in child support. The case has even garnered international … [Continue reading]

Family Law and Divorce Resources

If you're reading this blog, you probably realize that pretty much anything you need is on the interent. However, it's not always easy to find things. Here's a list of websites relating to divorce and family law that I refer to regularly: Family … [Continue reading]

Child Support Guidelines – May 2006 Changes

In May 2006, there will be some sweeping changes to Canada's child support laws. There are basically 3 major changes, as follows: 1. Since the Guidelines have come into effect, there has been a lot of litigation over what are know as "special … [Continue reading]

Top 10 Signs That A Technology Geek’s Marriage is in Trouble

Can you spot a loopy piece of code faster than a speeding bullet? Can you create security systems more powerful than a locomotive? Can you leap across multiple platforms in a single bound? If you answered yes to these questions, you may be a … [Continue reading]

Alabama Family Law Blog

I recently discovered an interesting new blog - the Alabama Family Law Blog. This is produced by the Mobile, Alabama firm of Sherman & Jeffries, LLC. The blog contains a wealth of important tips for people involved in family law litigation. Some … [Continue reading]

Disclosure Requirements for New Partners

One area of family law in which there tends to be a lot of misunderstanding is the effect of new partners on a person's child support and spousal support oblgations. That is, if you start living with someone else, will that affect how much child or … [Continue reading]

Married No Kids

I'm going to start adding some interviews to my blog to give people a wider range of information and opinion. As I'm sure people are aware, custody battles are probably the most difficult and vicious part of family law. People love their children … [Continue reading]

Divorce and Bankruptcy

The intersection between family law and bankruptcy is fairly complicated. If you're faced with that situation, it definitely makes sense to retain a lawyer who is experienced in the area of bankruptcy. Your family law lawyer is normally not the … [Continue reading]

Wikipedia and the Quality of Evidence in Legal Cases

In family law cases, decisions depend greatly upon the quality of the information and evidence before the court. Often the law is simple - for instance, for anything relating to children, the test is what is in their best interests. Or, the law is … [Continue reading]

Divorce and Children’s Mental Health

The Globe and Mail published news about a study conducted by Statistic Canada that concludes "Even before a marital breakup, young children of parents heading for divorce tend to develop mental health problems." Supposedly big news, but it's not a … [Continue reading]

Divorce Legal Fees

Sigrent wrote a comment on divorce legal fees in the forums. He complains about how high legal fees are, and then offers some proposals for ensuring that your legal fees are kept down. The issue of legal fees for divorce is a complex one, which I … [Continue reading]

Contino Again

David Giles responds to my comments on his analysis of the Contino decision. David states: "The point I was trying to make, and perhaps it didn't come across clearly, is that the dollars for days' argument may be more easily rebutted." What I've … [Continue reading]

More Comments on Contino

David Giles did a write up of the Contino decision. Overall, I think it's a pretty good analysis. However, I disagree with him on a couple of points. David says that the decision has "opened the door to shared parenting by removing the reduction … [Continue reading]

Child Support and Shared Custody – the Contino case

In cases of shared custody, in other words, cases where both parents have custody and the children spend approximately the same amount of time with each parent, the amount of child support is discretionary. How judges should exercise this discretion … [Continue reading]

International Divorce

There are a lot of issues in international divorce. Today, I'll focus on the issue of when a court in Ontario will take jurisdiction of a family law case with an international element. I'll also start by limiting things to when a couple initially … [Continue reading]

Welcome to the Ottawa Divorce Blog!

Welcome to my new divorce blog. I hope to make this a valuable addition to my website, providing you with divorce information, help and support. Please feel free to comment, as I'm always happy to hear from you. … [Continue reading]